Housing crisis causing tough commutes after long shifts
Nurses priced out of affordable homes are risking their health by driving long distances home after shifts. That was the stark warning from nurses at the RCN congress in Glasgow last month.Student Lindsay Branch rents a room in east London rather than commuting home to Essex each night
A debate on housing heard multiple examples of how nurses careers and health were being affected by a lack of affordable rented accommodation and soaring house prices. Neil Thompson, from the RCN UK safety representatives committee, told congress: High rents might be of no consequence if we still had acres of subsidised nursing accommodation for underpaid staff to live in. The impact of this is that many people find themselves isolated or in risky positions of being too tired at the end of a shift to get home safely.
According to the Halifax House Price Index, a...
Nurses priced out of affordable homes are risking their health by driving long distances home after shifts. That was the stark warning from nurses at the RCN congress in Glasgow last month.
A debate on housing heard multiple examples of how nurses’ careers – and health – were being affected by a lack of affordable rented accommodation and soaring house prices. Neil Thompson, from the RCN UK safety representatives committee, told congress: ‘High rents might be of no consequence if we still had acres of subsidised nursing accommodation for underpaid staff to live in. The impact of this is that many people find themselves isolated or in risky positions of being too tired at the end of a shift to get home safely.’
According to the Halifax House Price Index, a monthly snapshot of the UK housing market, the average house price for June was £216,823 – up 8.4% on the same time last year. The contrast with the £21,909 starting salary of a band 5 nurse in England and Wales (£21,692 in Northern Ireland and £22,218 in Scotland) could not be greater and means that, for many, getting a mortgage is out of the question without financial help.
In May, an RCN London survey revealed that 40% of nurses plan to leave the capital in the next five years because they cannot afford to stay. The college called on London mayor Sadiq Khan to deliver an action plan to support health staff to live in the capital to deliver safe patient care.
James Murray, who has been appointed by Mr Khan as deputy mayor for housing, told Nursing Standard: ‘We fully understand more needs to be done to deliver the new homes Londoners need and we have already started to work with local authorities, developers, the NHS and housing associations as well as accelerating homebuilding on Transport for London sites. We want to deliver thousands of genuinely low-cost homes so that those who work in the capital can afford to live here too.’
But the problem is not confined to London. RCN Scotland director Theresa Fyffe says band 5 nurses will struggle to get on the housing ladder unless there is a fundamental shift in the housing market. And nurses speaking in the RCN congress debate told of colleagues working in tourist hotspots such as Cornwall trying to get on the property ladder, but who were competing with wealthy people buying second homes.
Katie Sutton, a final-year nursing student from the Manchester central branch, said her job search was dictated by the areas she could afford to live in. ‘I shouldn’t have to consider whether I can afford to do a job where I care for people,’ she said.
Financial help may be available from the government to buy a home. Schemes include the UK-wide Help to Buy ISA, where the government will top up savings by 25% (up to a maximum of £3,000). Another initiative in England and Wales is the Help to Buy equity loan scheme, where the government offers a low-interest loan (known as an equity loan) towards a deposit on a new-build home.
A final option is buying a shared ownership home through a housing association. The UK-wide scheme allows a person to buy a share of the property and pay rent on the rest. Different rules apply in different UK countries.
Warren and Co is an independent financial and mortgage adviser for nurses and other public sector workers across the midlands and south west of England. Company director Julie Kennedy says uncertainty over how Brexit will affect house prices is another source of worry for those wanting to get on the housing ladder.
She adds that shared ownership or help to buy schemes could be a good option for nurses. ‘I say to clients they need to do what fits their personal circumstances,’ she says. ‘If you are in a position to buy, you should probably just go for it. There may never be a right time. Shared ownership is a good option as you would own, say, 40% of the property and would only need to put down 5% of that 40% as a deposit.’
For those who are not in a position to buy, many NHS organisations have their own accommodation offices that can offer advice to nurses looking for a place to live, both in key worker housing and the private sectors. Some hospitals, such as the Princess of Wales Hospital, Bridgend, offer on site staff accommodation. The hospital has 90 single occupancy units and 15 for couples.
Matthew Harrison, chief executive of Great Places Housing Group, which offers on-site hospital accommodation for healthcare workers in the north of England, says: ‘We should not be in a place where certain lower-income professions are unable to afford somewhere to live.’
Mature student Lindsay Branch (above) will be soon be starting as a band 5 adult nurse at Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust in London. She owns a property in Essex, but rents a room in Mile End, east London, for £500 a month.
She says: ‘The daily commute from Essex would be too far. I have been lucky because I have a friend with a home in London – it will take me half an hour to get to work, whereas I know of other graduates starting at the same time who will have a 90-minute journey because they can’t afford to live closer to work.’
‘It’s ridiculous. Something needs to be done.’
Want to read more?
Subscribe for unlimited access
Enjoy 1 month's access for £1 and get:
- Full access to nursing standard.com and the Nursing Standard app
- Monthly digital edition
- RCNi Portfolio and interactive CPD quizzes
- RCNi Learning with 200+ evidence-based modules
- 10 articles a month from any other RCNi journal